Food & drink in Cedarburg, WI

We read 120 businesses across 6 trades — the businesses someone searching in Cedarburg, WI is shown — and recorded what their Google reviews look like.

Measured 2026-09-24 from public Google listings. Ranked on reply behaviour, never on star rating.

One name turns up in four of the food and drink searches we read around Cedarburg. Stilt House Gastro Bar is among the businesses answering the most of their recent reviews for restaurants, cafés, coffee shops and bars, having answered 3 of its last 10 on a listing of 1435 reviews. A listing of 1435 reviews also heads the review counts in each of those four searches. These are the businesses someone searching in Cedarburg, WI is shown, not a register of what sits inside the city limits.

Among the restaurants we could measure, Tomaso's answered the most of its recent reviews: 9 of its last 10, on a listing of 898. The Stillery - Grafton answered 5 of 10 on 796 reviews. Over whole listing histories, the median restaurant of the 20 we read carries 451 reviews and a median rating of 4.5, and the most-reviewed carries 1435.

The coffee searches show a second name that recurs. Fiddleheads Coffee Cedarburg answered 4 of its last 10 on 458 reviews, and it appears among the cafés, the coffee shops, the bars and the bakeries named in this section. Among the coffee shops, Amy's Candy Kitchen answered 5 of 10 on a listing of 860. Among the bakeries, Fiddleheads is the business we can name for answering. Across whole listing histories, the median café we read carries 149 reviews, the median coffee shop 285.5, the median bar 161 and the median bakery 136; the median rating is 4.7 for cafés, coffee shops and bakeries, and 4.6 for bars. We can't see how the other businesses we read handled their recent reviews.

The food truck search holds the largest listing among the food and drink businesses in this section: Highland House, at 2045 reviews, which answered 2 of its last 10. In the same search, Firehouse Subs Grafton Marketplace answered 9 of 10 on 625 reviews, and Out & Out answered 8 of 10 on 1140. The median food truck listing we read carries 109.5 reviews, with a median rating of 4.55.

What to do about it

Open your listing and count how many of your last 10 reviews carry a reply from you. That is the same measure behind every reply figure above. The benchmark measured in this catchment is 68%, measured across all trades together, not food and drink alone. Among the restaurants we could measure, Tomaso's answered 9 of 10; among the food trucks, Firehouse Subs Grafton Marketplace answered 9 and Out & Out 8.

The review is the customer's; the reply is the part you write. Answer the next 10 reviews that arrive, the praise and the complaints alike, in a sentence or two that picks up something the customer actually mentioned. Keep it plain, thank them, and never argue in public. When those 10 are done, count again.

Restaurants

20 read · median 451 reviews · median rating 4.5

#BusinessAnsweredReviewsRating
1Tomaso's9 of 108984.6
2The Stillery - Grafton5 of 107964.6
3Stilt House Gastro Bar3 of 1014354.5

Cafés

20 read · median 149 reviews · median rating 4.7

#BusinessAnsweredReviewsRating
1Fiddleheads Coffee Cedarburg4 of 104584.5
2Stilt House Gastro Bar3 of 1014354.5

Coffee shops

20 read · median 285.5 reviews · median rating 4.7

#BusinessAnsweredReviewsRating
1Amy's Candy Kitchen5 of 108604.7
2Fiddleheads Coffee Cedarburg4 of 104584.5
3Stilt House Gastro Bar3 of 1014354.5

Bars

20 read · median 161 reviews · median rating 4.6

#BusinessAnsweredReviewsRating
1Fiddleheads Coffee Cedarburg4 of 104584.5
2Stilt House Gastro Bar3 of 1014354.5

Bakeries

20 read · median 136 reviews · median rating 4.7

#BusinessAnsweredReviewsRating
1Fiddleheads Coffee Cedarburg4 of 104584.5

Food trucks

20 read · median 109.5 reviews · median rating 4.55

#BusinessAnsweredReviewsRating
1Firehouse Subs Grafton Marketplace9 of 106254.4
2Out & Out8 of 1011404.5
3Highland House2 of 1020454.3
More in Cedarburg

The other groups we read in Cedarburg, WI

Same Cedarburg search, different trades — 140 more businesses read across 6 groups.

Hair, nails & barbering

20 businesses read across 1 trade · every trade had someone answering

Spa & aesthetics

40 businesses read across 2 trades · every trade had someone answering

Fitness & wellness

20 businesses read across 1 trade · every trade had someone answering

Dental & orthodontics

20 businesses read across 1 trade · every trade had someone answering

Pets

20 businesses read across 1 trade · every trade had someone answering

Shops & studios

20 businesses read across 1 trade · every trade had someone answering

Every trade in Cedarburg →

How it works

  1. Run the free audit. We read your public Google reviews and replies and send you the numbers: reply rate, the reviews still waiting for an answer, and the oldest of them — with the table on this page to put them beside.
  2. Claim your page. Pick your listing, and your QR card and short link are ready to print — from your own phone, no onboarding call.
  3. Get the weekly email. Every new review with its reply drafted, private feedback that came in, and the short list of what to fix on your listing and site.
  4. Approve, and that’s it. You press approve on the replies you like. The rest — the card, the page, the measuring — runs on its own.

What you get

Your review page

A printed QR card and a short link that open every review option — Google, Tripadvisor, Facebook — capture the customer’s email, and give an unhappy customer a private word first. About four minutes to a printable QR.

Reviews handled

Every new review on your platforms, with the reply drafted in your voice, in one weekly email. Negative ones first. You approve, edit or skip; nothing posts without you.

Local standing

Where you rank around your shop, what competitors are doing, what changed on your listing — with the exact fix for each. Recommendations can lead to better rankings and more visibility; no tool can promise a position, including ours.

What food & drink businesses around Cedarburg, WI do with their reviews
TradeMedian reviewsBest answeredYou
Restaurants4519 of 10the audit fills this in
Cafés1494 of 10the audit fills this in
Coffee shops285.55 of 10the audit fills this in
Bars1614 of 10the audit fills this in
Bakeries1364 of 10the audit fills this in
Food trucks109.59 of 10the audit fills this in
Get the free auditSee pricing

From $10/mo · Growth $29 · Pro $59 · cancel anytime · what you print is yours for life · Oh Local is not affiliated with Google.